Home
Experts
Ask An Expert
Why Car Insurance Quotes Vary

Why Car Insurance Prices Vary Across Companies

Have a question?

Ask a question, it’s free

Car Insurance

Insurance companies give me very different quotes. Why is the average cost of car insurance so different between insurance companies?

I’ve been shopping around for car insurance and have noticed that different insurance companies are giving me vastly different quotes. Can you explain why my average cost of car insurance varies so much between these companies? What factors could be causing such a discrepancy in the rates?

Nov 18, 2024 | Patrick Miller, Wilmington, Delaware

Answer

Mark Fitzpatrick

Head of Insurance, MoneyGeekUpdated December 17, 2024

Many factors are used for the pricing of an insurance policy, and they are mainly based on the pool of policyholders, the severity and frequency of loss events and an insurer’s capital reserve. Generally, a policy underwriter with a strong capital reserve and large market shares could offer competitive rates.

Have a question?

Ask a question, it’s free

Why Car Insurance Prices Vary Across Companies

Have a question?

Insurance companies give me very different quotes. Why is the average cost of car insurance so different between insurance companies?

Answer

Have a question?

Other Topics About Car Insurance

Vehicle Modifications & Insurance for Drivers with Disabilities (A Guide)

How to Defend Yourself Against Health Insurance Fraud and Scammers

How to Choose a Rental Property to Fit Your Needs

Average Cost of Life Insurance in May 2024

Cheapest Health Insurance in Louisiana (2024 Plans)

How Does Life Insurance Work?

The Average Cost of Health Insurance in 2024

Cheapest Car Insurance in Maine (June 2024)

Senior Driver Guide: Advice & Resources for Older Adults On the Road

Cheapest Car Insurance for Teens 2024

The Connection Between Physical and Financial Health

Best Life Insurance for 60-Year-Olds in January 2024

Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in 2024

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies (July 2024)

Drownings Reach a 5-Year High, and 1 in 5 Victims Are 19 or Younger

States Where Homeowners & Renters Are Most At-Risk for Hail Damage in 2022

Cheap Motorcycle Insurance: The Most Affordable Motorcycle Insurance Companies and Policies for 2024

Essential Guide to Renting a Car for the First Time

Cheap Car Insurance for Young Drivers

What Is General Liability Insurance Coverage and Do You Need It?

Best Car Insurance for Young Drivers in 2024

Cheapest Health Insurance in Florida (2024 Plans)

Term vs. Whole Life Insurance

How Sleep Impacts Your Finances and Career

Are Pre-Existing Mental Health Conditions Covered by Health Insurance?

"Can You Buy Life Insurance on Your Parents? "

Average Cost of Life Insurance in May 2024

Learn About Driving Anxiety & How to Manage It

How Does Life Insurance Work?

Cities With the Most (& Least) Climate Risk Today

Is Life Insurance Worth It?

Cities With the Most (& Least) Climate Risk Today

Cheapest Car Insurance in North Carolina (June 2024)

Wildfires by the Numbers

Understanding Car Insurance for Active-Duty Military Members and Veterans

How to Be a Responsible Pet Owner: Advice & Resources

Best Term Life Insurance Companies in February 2024

Guide to Life Insurance Death Benefits and Final Expenses

List of Car Insurance Companies: Largest Companies in '23

How to Get the Most Out of Your Health Insurance Plan

The Best Renters Insurance for 2024: Affordable Rates & Great Customer Service

Best and Cheapest Car Insurance After a DUI (2024)

Emissions on the Road: Environmental Impact of Automobiles and the Benefits of Going Green

A Guide to Obtaining Insurance for Mental Health Care

Guide to Vaccinations: Costs, Information & Expert Panel

Pedestrian Crash Analysis Shows That Even at Low Speeds, Accidents Often Cause Severe Injuries

Balancing Social Media Use and Your Financial and Mental Health

Best Car Insurance for Young Drivers in 2024

How to Prevent Floods From Damaging Your Home

Instant and Free Car Insurance Quotes Online (2024)

Guide to Health Insurance for Students & Young Adults

A Guide on Safe Night Driving

10 Types of Small Business Insurance Coverage to Consider

Homeowners Insurance Deductible

Cheapest Life Insurance Companies in March 2024

Ultimate Guide to Wills and Why They Are Important

"Can You Buy Life Insurance on Your Parents? "

Best Car Insurance for Young Drivers in 2024

The Average Cost of Health Insurance in 2024

How to Transfer Car Insurance & Driving Credentials to a New State

Guide to Health Insurance for Students & Young Adults

Home Death and Injury by the Numbers

Term vs. Whole Life Insurance

Best and Cheapest Car Insurance After a DUI (2024)

Managing Federal Taxes on Life Insurance Proceeds

Managing Federal Taxes on Life Insurance Proceeds

Average Cost of Owning a Car

Pet Ownership Guide for Older Adults

How to Get Car Insurance in 6 Steps

Best and Cheapest Car Insurance for Drivers With Bad Credit

Ultimate Guide to Driving With Pets

The Cheapest Car Insurance in California (June 2024)

Cheapest Health Insurance in Texas (2024 Plans)

The Best Cheap Car Insurance for Seniors in July 2024