The Best Cheap Car Insurance for Sports Cars (2024)

Enter your ZIP code to get started

Shield

Free. Simple. Secure.

fact checked icon

Updated: October 25, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Driving a sports car comes with some unique benefits, but it can also mean high insurance costs. Sports car insurance rates are relatively high because these vehicles tend to have higher repair costs and are more prone to collisions.

Although insurance for a sports car insurance is higher than for a standard vehicle, some companies offer more affordable coverage options than others. Because personal factors like your location, credit history or how you store your vehicle also affect rates, it’s crucial that you compare quotes from several companies to find the best option for you.

Table of Contents

Key Takeaways

blueCheck icon

The cost of sports car insurance varies between providers. Taking the time to gather and compare quotes can result in savings worth several hundreds of dollars.

blueCheck icon

There is no single best company offering car insurance for sports cars. The provider with the best cheap sports car insurance for you depends on what type of vehicle you drive.

blueCheck icon

Although insurance for sports cars is undeniably more expensive than standard vehicles, utilizing discounts, raising your deductible or storing your vehicle when you aren’t driving it can reduce your premiums.

Compare Insurance Rates

Ensure you are getting the best rate for your insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

widget-location-pin
Insurance Rates

The Cheapest Sports Cars to Insure

The cost of insurance for sports cars varies by make and model. For example, if you have a BMW i8, your annual premium would be approximately $2,810 for full coverage. If you drive a Ford Mustang, you’ll pay $1,239 less for full coverage, on average.

Excluding the Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat, the average sports car insurance premium is $1,726 per year. The table below shows how much it takes to insure different models of sports cars.

Cheapest Sports Cars to Insure

The Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance by Vehicle

Finding the most affordable carrier for your vehicle is crucial because insurance costs can vary widely between different sports cars and providers. MoneyGeek compiled a list of some of the most popular sports cars and analyzed quotes from insurers to find the best cheap provider for each vehicle.

Table of Contents

Porsche Taycan

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

First on our list is the Porsche Taycan. It’s one of the best sports cars in the market with cheap average insurance rates.

MoneyGeek compared various carriers and found that GEICO offers the best cheap full coverage sports car insurance for the Porsche Taycan. With an average annual premium of $981, it has the most affordable insurance for this sports car. This rate is $551 less than that offered by the most expensive provider — Allstate — at $1,532 per year.

Our internal rating system looks beyond affordability and considers other factors, such as a provider’s financial strength. GEICO also received a perfect score in this area. It means they’ll have no problems reimbursing legitimate claims even after major catastrophes like hurricanes and wildfires.

Porsche Taycan Insurance Rates

Nissan 350Z

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

You can purchase the best cheap sports car insurance for the Nissan 350Z from GEICO. They rated high on affordability since their policy only costs $1,128 per year on average — that’s $466 less expensive than Allstate’s average rate of $1,431.

GEICO also had a perfect score in financial strength, which means the likelihood that they’ll still be operating when you file a claim is high — even if it happens years from now.

Another carrier offering cheap car insurance for this sports car is USAA, but their policies are only available to former and current military members and their families.

Nissan 350Z Insurance Rates

Ford Mustang EcoBoost

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Progressive

MoneyGeek evaluated several carriers offering policies for the Ford Mustang EcoBoost. Our analysis showed Progressive has the best cheap insurance for this sports car. For $1,178 per year on average for a full-coverage policy, Progressive’s high financial strength ratings can assure you that they'll process your claim efficiently and objectively. Of the various areas MoneyGeek used to evaluate providers, Progressive also scored high in policyholder complaints (meaning they received fewer complaints than average) and affordability.

Coverage with Progressive costs $694 less than it does with Allied, the most expensive provider for this vehicle.

USAA offers a lower average annual full coverage premium at $1,076, but its policies are only available active-duty military members, veterans and qualifying family members.

Ford Mustang EcoBoost Insurance Rates

Subaru WRX

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

You can find cheap sports car insurance from various companies. When it comes to the Subaru WRX, GEICO is your best bet.

In addition to offering the cheapest, widely available rates for this vehicle at $1,155 per year, GEICO also received a perfect score for financial stability. GEICO’s premium is significantly less expensive than Allied’s — the most costly provider for this vehicle at $1,995 per year.

If you are a member of the military community, USAA is another solid option. You can purchase a full coverage policy for an annual rate of $1,136.

Subaru WRX Insurance Rates

Chevrolet Camaro LS

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

With a $1,339 average annual premium for full coverage, GEICO is a solid choice if you’re looking for cheap sports car insurance for the Chevrolet Camaro LS. Compare this cost to that offered by Allstate — the most expensive provider for this car — at $1,789 per year. MoneyGeek’s analysis showed that GEICO scored high in two specific areas — affordability and financial stability.

Among the providers MoneyGeek evaluated, USAA also offers cheap sports car insurance. Their rate is lower than GEICO’s, but you can only purchase coverage with them if you have a military background.

Chevrolet Camaro LS Insurance Rates

Subaru BRZ

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

On average, the cost of sports car insurance for the Subaru BRZ is $1,495 per year for full coverage. MoneyGeek compared quotes from multiple providers and found several that offered policies with rates lower than that. GEICO offers the cheapest insurance coverage for this vehicle at $1,155 per year, on average.

The difference between GEICO’s coverage and Allied’s, the most expensive provider, was $937. This dramatic difference illustrates the importance of comparing rates and finding the cheapest coverage for you.

Subaru BRZ Insurance Rates

Chevrolet Camaro SS

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

GEICO offers the most affordable insurance for the Chevrolet Camaro SS at an average rate of $1,396 per year for full coverage. Allied, the most expensive insurer for this vehicle, charges $1,776 for the same coverage, meaning you could save $610 by purchasing insurance from GEICO.

Another option for cheap sports car insurance is USAA, with a full coverage policy costing $1,166. However, keep in mind that their insurance is only available to current and former military members and their families.

Chevrolet Camaro SS Insurance Rates

Dodge Challenger R/T

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

MoneyGeek compared several policies from different providers and found GEICO to offer the best cheap sports car insurance for the Dodge Challenger R/T. With an annual average premium of $1,460 for full coverage, it’s no surprise that GEICO scored high in affordability. On average, a policy with GEICO is $393 less expensive than coverage with the most expensive insurer, Allstate.

USAA is the cheapest sports car insurance option for this vehicle, but their policies are only available to members of the military community.

Dodge Challenger R/T Insurance Rates

Ford Mustang GT

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

If you’re looking for the auto insurer that offers the best cheap sports car insurance for a Ford Mustang GT, MoneyGeek’s study determined that GEICO is the top choice.

With a policy costing $1,359 per year on average for full coverage, coverage with GEICO costs $568 less on average than Allstate, this vehicle’s most expensive insurer.

USAA is another option for cheap sports car insurance. Their policy is more affordable than GEICO’s, costing an annual rate of $1,298 for full coverage. If you belong to a military family, this may be a good choice for you.

Ford Mustang GT Insurance Rates

Toyota 86

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: GEICO

GEICO has the best cheap insurance among providers, offering policies for the Toyota 86 at $1,261 per year for full coverage. We found that Allstate is the most expensive carrier for this vehicle, charging an average of $2,251 annually for the same coverage.

If you come from a military family, USAA is another solid, inexpensive option. Its full coverage policy has an average annual premium of $1,184, but coverage is restricted to members of the military community.

Toyota 86 Insurance Rates

Chevrolet Corvette

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Nationwide

Based on MoneyGeek’s internal rating system, Nationwide offers the best cheap full coverage car insurance policy for a Chevrolet Corvette at $1,127 annually, on average. Of the four areas considered, Nationwide scores high in complaints and stability. It also received a perfect score for affordability. This policy is $961 cheaper than the most expensive insurance option — Allstate — which costs $2,088 per year.

Chevrolet Corvette Insurance Rates

Ford Mustang Mach-E

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Progressive

If you’re driving a Ford Mustang Mach-E, your best option for affordable insurance is likely offered by Progressive. A full coverage policy for this vehicle costs $1,554 per year on average — that’s $1,134 less expensive than coverage from Allstate, the most costly provider for this car.

Progressive boasts of high scores in complaints, affordability and stability. It indicates that most users don’t express dissatisfaction with how their claims are processed — so you can expect the same experience. It’s currently one of the strongest national insurers, which reflects in its stability rating.

The only carrier with a lower rate is USAA. Its full coverage policy costs an average of $1,295 annually but isn’t widely available. However, its coverage is restricted to members of the military community.

Ford Mustang Mach-E Insurance Rates

Chevrolet Camaro ZL1

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Progressive

Progressive is a solid choice if you have a Chevrolet Camaro ZL1. Among the providers MoneyGeek evaluated, it offers the best widely available, cheap sports car insurance policy for this vehicle at an average cost of $1,640 per year for full coverage.

Although Progressive offers cheap sports car insurance for the Chevrolet ZL1, USAA’s rate is $95 less. If you belong to a military family and qualify for coverage with this insurer, this may be a good option for you.

Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 Insurance Rates

Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Nationwide

The Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat is one of the most popular sports cars available in the market. If you’re driving one and looking for where to purchase the best cheap insurance for this sports car, MoneyGeek’s analysis shows Nationwide is your best bet. A full coverage policy for this vehicle from Nationwide will cost you $1,773 per year, on average. That’s $1,253 cheaper than the most expensive carrier, Allstate.

Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat Insurance Rates

Nissan GT-R

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Nationwide

The company with the best cheap sports car insurance for the Nissan GT-R is Nationwide at an average premium $1,967 per year for full coverage. Nationwide’s policy is $1,601 cheaper than Allstate, the most expensive provider for this vehicle, on average.

Nissan GT-R Insurance Rates

BMW i8

Best Cheap Sports Car Insurance Option: Progressive

Last on our list is the BMW i8. You can purchase coverage from several carriers, but the best cheap full coverage insurance for this sports car comes from Progressive at $1,750 per year, on average. Coverage from Allstate, the most expensive provider for this vehicle, costs an astounding $2,191 more.

BMW i8 Insurance Rates

Sport Cars Topics you may be interested in:

blueCheck icon
blueCheck icon

How to Save on the Cost of Sports Car Insurance

Insurance coverage tends to be more expensive for sports cards. Fortunately, there are several measures you can take to reduce your annual premium.

  1. 1
    Shop around for the best insurance rates.

    Insurance rates for your sports car will vary between providers. It isn’t unusual to see a difference of several hundreds of dollars between policies from two carriers. Shopping around for comparable quotes (same coverage level) gives you a better idea of the price range and can help you choose the best policy for your budget.

  2. 2
    Take advantage of bundling your policies.

    Most insurers agencies offer significant discounts if you purchase multiple policies from them, such as home and auto. If you already have homeowners insurance, see if your provider can give you a lower rate if you also get an auto insurance policy from them.

  3. 3
    Ask about discounts you may qualify for.

    Check what discount programs your insurance provider offers — you’d be surprised to see which ones apply to you. Carriers offer premium discounts for various reasons. Sometimes, you may be eligible for discounts based on individual characteristics, such as being a safe driver or a good student. Other times, companies provide reductions for safety features, like having an anti-theft device installed in your car. One of the most significant discounts comes if you insure multiple vehicles with the same policy provider.

  4. 4
    Use an insurance comparison tool.

    Requesting quotes online is an efficient way of checking rates for different companies. You can shorten the process further by using an insurance comparison tool. Although it won’t show you other premium-reduction opportunities (such as discounts), it can help you narrow down your search for the best cheap sports car insurance company.

  5. 5
    Raise your deductible.

    After you file a claim, your deductible is the amount of money you pay out of pocket before your car insurance provider begins helping with costs: the higher your deductible, the lower your annual premium. However, be sure to choose a deductible that you could reasonably pay if you got into an accident. Note that full coverage policies include two separate deductibles — one for collision and one for comprehensive — but no deductible applies to liability coverage.

  6. 6
    Consider pay-per-mile coverage.

    A traditional car insurance policy usually uses statistics to determine premium prices. Some insurers use a different system known as pay-as-you-drive or pay-per-mile coverage, where your premium changes based on how many miles you drive. The less you drive, the less you pay. If you don’t take your sports car on the road frequently, this might be an ideal, low-cost insurance option. Some insurers also offer a telematics discount, which involves downloading an app to your phone that tracks how and when you drive. The safer and less frequently you drive, the better discount you can receive.

  7. 7
    Opt for vehicle storage in the off-season.

    Consider your driving habits and see if there are certain months or times of year you don’t drive your car. Some auto insurance companies allow you to drop collision insurance if you’re storing your vehicle for an extended period (typically 30 days or more). Temporarily dropping this coverage usually results in a lower premium since you’re only paying for comprehensive and liability coverage. However, if you’re still making payments on your car, this option may not be available to you.

mglogo icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

Insurance professionals recommend keeping comprehensive coverage for garaged vehicles to protect them from fire, theft, vandalism and storm damage to the location where they are parked. Many lenders will also require you to keep collision and comprehensive regardless of usage if the car loan is still active —Mark Friedlander, Director, Corporate Communications, Insurance Information Institute

Sports Car Insurance FAQ

If you own a sports car, you may have some questions about how to find affordable coverage. These commonly asked questions can provide you with more information about sports car insurance.

Why does sports car insurance cost more?
How much does car insurance cost for a sports car?
What is the best company for sports car insurance?

About Mark Fitzpatrick

Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick is a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's Head of Insurance. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. He has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.

Read Full Bio »
Insurance
Mortgage
Credit Cards
Loans
About MoneyGeekPressPrivacy PolicySitemap
Copyright © 2024 MoneyGeek.com. All Rights Reserved Terms of Use