Best West Virginia Home and Auto Bundle Insurance Companies (2024)

With a MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100, State Farm is the best company for an auto and home insurance bundle in West Virginia. It’s also the cheapest at $2,027 per year.

By Mark Fitzpatrick

Edited by Kathryn Schroeder

Updated: December 2, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Key Takeaways

In West Virginia, State Farm emerges as the top provider for home and auto insurance bundles with a MoneyGeek score of 85, offering the most significant bundle discount and competitive pricing, while Nationwide, the runner-up with a score of 78, provides above-average satisfaction but lags in affordability compared to State Farm; additionally, USAA is the best option for military members, albeit with limited availability.

In West Virginia, State Farm and Nationwide are the top providers for affordable home and auto insurance bundles, with annual premiums of around $2,027 and $2,112, respectively, while USAA offers the lowest rate at approximately $1,729 but is only available to military members and their families.

The cheapest non-bundled insurance combination in West Virginia is pairing State Farm auto insurance at approximately $845 per year with Nationwide home insurance at roughly $1,448 per year, totaling an average of $2,293 per year, which is $266 more expensive than the cheapest auto-home bundle offered by State Farm at around $2,027 per year.

Why trust MoneyGeek? West Virginia bundle rates are supported by our analysis of quotes and ratings. The best bundles are based on our proprietary scoring system that balances cost and discounts with service experience.

32Quotes Analyzed

4Companies Compared

1Zip Codes

The Best Home and Auto Bundles in West Virginia

MoneyGeek considered affordability, customer service and discounts when scoring insurance companies in West Virginia. Our study found that the best companies for auto and home insurance bundling in the state are:

State Farm: MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100
Nationwide: MoneyGeek score of 78 out of 100

State Farm offers the best auto and home insurance in West Virginia, receiving the highest score for a bundle discount and second-highest scores for auto satisfaction and home satisfaction. Nationwide, our runner-up, lagged in affordability with its discount but earned above-average ratings on auto and home satisfaction.

pros

Scored 4 out of 5 for auto and home satisfaction

Earned a perfect discount score

Has rental car and/or travel reimbursement coverage

cons

Doesn’t offer new car or better car replacement

Doesn’t offer discount for going paperless

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

For those who want a company that offers a great combination of affordability and quality service, State Farm is the best option in West Virginia. The insurer earned high customer satisfaction ratings for its auto and homeowners insurance. It also provides a bundle discount of around 23%, lowering the average annual premium to $2,027 and saving customers a whopping $596 on average.

Regarding its car insurance, State Farm offers typical add-on coverages like rental car and/or travel reimbursement. That pays for car rental expenses up to a chosen limit and travel expenses up to $500. Additionally, it covers up to $500 in repayment of the deductible for a covered accident in a rental vehicle. It’s worth noting, however, that State Farm doesn’t have other common optional coverages, such as new car replacement or gap insurance.

State Farm homeowners policies can be supplemented with rare add-on coverages. These include home systems protection, which covers damages to permanently installed systems due to an abrupt and accidental mechanical or electrical breakdown. State Farm also offers loss assessment to members of a homeowners association (HOA).

Read MoneyGeek's State Farm Auto Insurance Review

pros

Scored 4 out of 5 for auto and home satisfaction

Offers identity theft add-on coverage for car insurance policy

Offers a discount for automatic payment

cons

Earned a score of 3 out of 5 for its bundle discount

Lacks better car replacement and new car replacement

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Another option for the best auto and home insurance in West Virginia is Nationwide. The company combines above-average customer service with affordable rates, making it our runner-up pick in the state. Moreover, Nationwide offers a bundle discount of around 10%, reducing the annual premium to approximately $2,112.

Nationwide offers two unique optional coverages for auto insurance: identity theft and total loss deductible waiver. The former covers identity theft or fraud expenses up to $25,000, whereas the latter pays for the comprehensive or collision deductible if a car is declared a total loss after an accident.

In addition, there is an available uncommon add-on coverage for a Nationwide homeowners policy: better roof replacement coverage. It covers the cost of replacing a roof with safer and stronger roofing materials after a covered loss.

Read MoneyGeek's Nationwide Auto Insurance Review

The Best Home and Auto Bundles in West Virginia for Military Backgrounds

According to MoneyGeek’s research, USAA ranks as the best company offering an auto and home insurance bundle in West Virginia. However, its availability is limited to military members, veterans and their families. Those eligible for a USAA policy can enjoy a low rate plus quality service.

MoneyGeek Top Pick

USAA

MoneyGeek found that USAA offers the best auto and home insurance in West Virginia for those with a military background. Although it already offers a cheap auto or home policy, you can further lower your premium by around 6% if you choose to bundle at an average annual rate of $1,729.

Note that USAA doesn’t have any rare optional coverages. It offers common ones, such as rental car reimbursement for auto insurance and home rental for homeowners insurance. Rental car reimbursement pays for a rental car while your vehicle is being repaired after a covered loss. Meanwhile, home rental protects you and your guests when you rent a room or your entire home.

The Best Home and Auto Bundle Discounts in West Virginia

On average, West Virginians lower their insurance costs by 15% and save $372 a year when they bundle auto and home insurance policies. MoneyGeek’s study discovered that State Farm offers the most significant bundle discount at around 23%, whereas USAA has the smallest discount at roughly 6%.

The biggest discount doesn’t automatically guarantee the cheapest rate. For example, USAA offers the lowest quote for bundled policies at approximately $1,729 per year, even with the smallest bundle discount. But it is only available to military personnel, so State Farm offers the largest bundle discount and lowest price in West Virginia to all residents at around $2,027.

Conversely, Allstate has the most expensive annual premium at roughly $2,465 after around an 18% bundle discount.

Home and Auto Bundle Discount in West Virginia

The Cheapest Home and Auto Bundles in West Virginia

MoneyGeek found that the two companies with, on average, the most affordable auto and home bundles in West Virginia, regardless of discounts, are:

State Farm: $2,027 per year
Nationwide: $2,112 per year

USAA may be an excellent option for military members, veterans and their families living in the state. It offers a home and auto bundle to eligible customers at approximately $1,729 per year.

MoneyGeek Top Pick

State Farm

The cheapest option for an auto and home insurance bundle in West Virginia is State Farm. Its bundle costs an average of $2,027 per year, which is around 23% more affordable than getting car insurance and homeowners insurance separately.

If you’re looking for potential savings, State Farm has several discount opportunities for its policyholders. You can earn a discount for insuring multiple cars, safe driving and having airbags and an anti-theft system. Additionally, you may qualify for the company’s new home, home renovation and protective device discounts.


State Farm	$2,027
Nationwide	$2,112
Allstate	$2,456

The Cheapest Non-Bundle Insurance Combinations in West Virginia

An alternative option to save on insurance is to get policies from two different companies. That means pairing the most affordable car insurance you can find with the cheapest homeowners insurance.

At an average cost of $2,293 per year, pairing State Farm auto insurance (around $845 per year) with Nationwide home insurance (roughly $1,448 per year) results in the cheapest bundled combination in West Virginia.

Still, it’s more affordable to bundle policies with the same company in West Virginia. Case in point, State Farm offers its home and auto bundle at approximately $2,027 per year. That’s around $266 more affordable than the cheapest bundled combination we found in West Virginia.


State Farm	Nationwide	$2,293
Allstate	Nationwide	$2,566
Nationwide	State Farm	$2,674
State Farm	Allstate	$2,727
Nationwide	Allstate	$2,778
Allstate	State Farm	$2,896

Should You Bundle Home and Auto Insurance in West Virginia?

In most cases, it’s more affordable to bundle auto and homeowners policies with the same insurance company in West Virginia. Some of the benefits include cheaper rates and convenience. However, it’s important to note that a home and auto policy bundle from certain providers can be expensive. Thus, buying separate policies may be cheaper and more budget-friendly.

Bundle discounts in West Virginia can save you between 6% and 23% per year.

Based on MoneyGeek’s analysis, State Farm provides the biggest bundle discount in West Virginia at around 23%. Bundling home and auto insurance with this provider can save you roughly $596 annually. Conversely, choosing to bundle policies with USAA — if you qualify as a military member — can reduce your rate by 6%, but it may still result in a lower premium than what State Farm offers.

Bundles are a convenient way to combine your most important property insurance policies.

It’s often better to pay one company for both your car and homeowners policies — your account will be easier to manage. Plus, your insurance provider can offer a discount to help you save on insurance.

In rare cases, it might be better not to bundle in West Virginia.

In West Virginia, the cheapest bundled insurance company combination MoneyGeek found (State Farm auto insurance and Nationwide home insurance) costs roughly $2,293 per year. Although it’s not cheaper than a bundle from State Farm (around $2,027 per year), it’s possible you may get a more affordable bundled combination by shopping around and comparing rates.

About Mark Fitzpatrick

Mark Fitzpatrick is a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's Head of Insurance. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. He has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.

Read Full Bio »