Is Supplemental Life Insurance Worth It?


Deciding whether supplemental life insurance is worth it involves assessing your personal needs and financial situation. For some, it offers an essential safety net, mainly when traditional term life insurance isn't sufficient due to health or age. You also may want to enroll if your employer provides supplemental employee life insurance coverage at no cost.

However, specific limitations and supplemental life insurance rates might lower the appeal of this coverage for others, particularly when more adaptable and cost-effective alternatives like term life insurance are available. Evaluate your finances to determine if this type of insurance aligns with your goals.

Key Takeaways

blueCheck icon

Supplemental life insurance adds extra coverage to existing life insurance, enhancing financial security.

blueCheck icon

Supplemental life insurance coverage is best for those with specific financial needs that basic life insurance does not fully cover.

blueCheck icon

Before purchasing supplemental life insurance, it's wise to consider rates, coverage adequacy, policy limitations and financial stability.

What Is Supplemental Life Insurance?

Supplemental life insurance is an additional policy that you can purchase to complement your existing life insurance coverage. Most consumers buy supplemental life insurance through their employers.

This type of insurance aims to fill any coverage gaps that your central policy might leave, offering your beneficiaries an extra measure of financial security. Although it enhances your existing coverage, it's important to note that supplemental life insurance has distinct limitations. Understanding its structure and how it complements your primary life insurance helps assess its value in your overall insurance strategy.

Basic vs. Supplemental Life Insurance

When evaluating basic life insurance and supplemental life insurance, it's necessary to understand the distinct roles each plays in your financial security plan. Basic life insurance provides a foundational level of coverage, typically offered to eligible private-sector employees as term or whole life policies. It is designed to meet the essential needs of beneficiaries in the event of the policyholder’s death. This coverage is often enough for most families to handle significant financial obligations such as mortgages, outstanding debts and living expenses.

Supplemental life insurance offers additional coverage beyond the basic policy. This can be vital for individuals who require extra financial security due to higher liabilities or to provide for special circumstances. Examples of supplemental life insurance coverage include supplemental employee life insurance, supplemental spouse life insurance and supplemental group life insurance. These policies can complement your primary insurance by covering extra expenses not typically handled by basic life insurance, such as children’s education or specific debts.

Understanding the difference between supplemental and basic life insurance will help you make informed decisions about your insurance needs. Depending on your personal and financial situation, the additional coverage provided by supplemental life insurance might be a worthwhile investment to ensure that your coverage sufficiently meets your family’s future needs.

Who Should Buy Supplemental Life Insurance

Though the convenience of buying supplemental life insurance through your employer might be appealing, it's generally not the best choice for consumers. More flexible and cost-effective alternatives, like term life insurance, are usually better suited to your needs and circumstances.

Despite its limitations, there are circumstances where supplemental life insurance might be beneficial:

  • Zero-Cost Benefit: If your workplace provides supplemental employee life insurance at no cost, consider accepting it. For more comprehensive coverage, think about supplementing it with term life insurance.
  • Inability to Increase Coverage: If your age or health conditions preclude you from increasing your coverage through term life policies, supplemental life insurance can provide the extra protection you need, although typically at a higher cost.
  • Employer Incentives: When employers offer incentives or matching contributions, employee supplemental life insurance can become a valuable part of the benefits package.
  • Specific Coverage Needs: Supplemental life insurance coverage can fill these gaps if your current policy doesn't cover particular risks or scenarios relevant to you.

Before you decide, consider how supplemental life insurance coverage will serve your unique situation to determine its value for your financial planning.

Why Supplemental Life Insurance Often Falls Short

It's important to know that supplemental life insurance may fall short of term life insurance for several reasons. We highlight these potential disadvantages below:

  1. 1

    Cost

    Supplemental life insurance rates are typically higher for comparable levels of coverage when placed side by side with standalone term life insurance policies. The cost difference can be especially striking for those in good health.

  2. 2

    Flexibility

    Supplemental life insurance through an employer often lacks the flexibility of term life policies. For instance, you might be unable to keep your policy if you change jobs.

  3. 3

    Low Coverage Amounts

    Supplemental life insurance often provides relatively low coverage amounts, which might not adequately meet your family's financial needs in the event of your passing.

  4. 4

    False Security

    Supplemental life insurance coverage tied to a primary policy can create a sense of false security, potentially leading to underestimating coverage needs.

Factors to Consider Before Buying Supplemental Life

Carefully evaluating your options before purchasing supplemental life insurance is a wise first step. Key considerations include:

  • Adequacy of Existing Coverage: Assess whether your current life insurance meets your financial responsibilities.
  • Cost vs. Benefit: Evaluate the premiums for supplemental insurance against the value of additional coverage provided.
  • Policy Limitations: Be aware of any restrictions, such as portability with job changes or coverage ceilings.
  • Financial Stability: Consider whether the added premium is manageable within your budget.
  • Health and Age Factors: Reflect on how your age and health status might affect the cost and availability of supplemental insurance.
  • Future Insurance Needs: Anticipate future financial requirements to determine whether supplemental insurance is appropriate for long-term planning.
  • Employer's Terms: Review the details of your employer's supplemental insurance offer, including any specific advantages or drawbacks.
  • Alternative Options: Consider other insurance products that offer better coverage or more value for your specific circumstances.

Your decision should ideally reflect a balance between your current coverage, financial objectives and potential future needs.

Other Types of Supplemental Life Insurance

Apart from employer-offered supplemental life insurance, several other types of supplemental insurance policies are available. Each comes with its unique set of characteristics and potential drawbacks:

    coupleL icon

    Supplemental Spouse Life Insurance

    These policies provide additional coverage for the policyholder's spouse. However, supplemental spouse life insurance often carries higher premiums than an individual term life policy, especially if the spouse is in good health.

    coupleG icon

    Supplemental Partner Life Insurance

    This type of coverage allows individuals to purchase additional life insurance for their partners, typically within a business or domestic partnership. Depending on the insurance provider, this type of insurance might not be marketed as "supplemental partner life insurance" but as part of broader life insurance policies where the insured can designate any beneficiary, including a business or domestic partner. Here are some key aspects:

    • Business Partnerships: In a business context, supplemental partner life insurance can help protect each partner's financial interest in the company. If one partner dies, the policy payout can help the surviving partner(s) manage buy-sell agreements, cover operational costs or facilitate the transfer of the deceased partner’s share without liquidating business assets.
    • Domestic Partnerships: For nonmarried couples, this insurance can provide financial protection similar to that spouses receive under supplemental spouse life insurance. It ensures that the surviving partner has financial support in the event of the other partner’s death, which can be crucial for maintaining their standard of living. It's important to note that the availability and terms of such coverage can vary by insurance provider and state regulations.
    death icon

    Supplemental Burial Insurance

    Also known as final expense insurance, this policy covers funeral and burial costs. However, the premiums can be high, and coverage may be limited, especially considering the overall financial needs of the family after the policyholder's death. A regular term life policy generally offers more coverage for the same or a lower premium. Also, planning for these costs earlier in life can ensure you have money aside to pay for final expenses rather than paying for a policy. See our ranking of the best burial and final expense policies.

    childCare3 icon

    Supplemental Child Insurance

    These policies provide a payout if the insured child passes away. However, the financial need for such insurance is often low, as children typically don't contribute to family income. It's generally more cost-effective to ensure parents have adequate life insurance coverage.

    injury icon

    Supplemental Accidental Death and Dismemberment Insurance

    These policies pay out if the policyholder dies or is seriously injured in an accident. While it may seem beneficial, a comprehensive life and disability insurance policy usually offers broader coverage at a more reasonable price.

    workplace icon

    Supplemental Group Life Insurance

    This type of plan typically refers to additional life insurance coverage that an employer offers to all eligible employees as part of a group policy. Supplemental group life insurance is often available without medical underwriting, and employees may choose to purchase higher coverage at group rates, which can be more cost-effective than individual policies.

Term Life Insurance Advantages

If you're considering supplemental life insurance, it's worthwhile to also think about the alternative options available to you. Term life insurance offers a host of advantages over supplemental life insurance, such as:

  1. 1

    Cost-Effectiveness

    Term life insurance provides considerable coverage at a fraction of the cost of permanent life insurance, making it possible to secure adequate coverage without exceeding your budget.

  2. 2

    Flexibility

    Term life insurance allows you to choose your coverage amount and beneficiaries. You can also keep your policy irrespective of job transitions.

  3. 3

    Laddering Option

    You're not limited to just one term life insurance policy. You can hold multiple policies simultaneously, allowing you to adjust your coverage in line with evolving financial obligations. This strategy, called "life insurance laddering," may be an effective way to maximize your policies without purchasing supplemental coverage.

FAQ About Supplemental Life Insurance

Explore commonly asked questions about supplemental life insurance to determine whether adding it to your financial planning and insurance strategy is worth it.

What is supplemental life insurance?

How does supplemental life insurance differ from standard life insurance policies?

Is supplemental life insurance worth the cost?

Can you keep your supplemental life insurance if you change jobs?

Should you choose supplemental life insurance over increasing your current coverage?

What is supplemental life insurance used for?

Why is supplemental life insurance bad?

How does supplemental life insurance pay out benefits?

What is supplemental child life insurance?

What is spousal supplemental life insurance?

How much supplemental life insurance should you get?

Is supplemental life insurance pre-tax?

How does supplemental life insurance work?

What does supplemental life insurance cover?

Is supplemental life insurance term or whole?

What is supplemental life and AD&D insurance?

What’s the difference between basic and supplemental life insurance?

What happens to supplemental life insurance when you leave a job?

What is voluntary supplemental life insurance?

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick is a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's Head of Insurance. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. He has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.