When Should You Refinance Your Mortgage?

Got questions about refinancing your home loan? We've asked a panel of home lending experts to provide the answers.

Loading...
Bill Banfield
Vice President
Loading...
Lee M. Eisenberg
President
Loading...
Mari Adam
President
Ask the experts:

What should homeowners look for when comparing refinance offers?

President & CEO of Michigan Legacy Credit Union

Homeowners should consider multiple factors, including the interest rate, closing costs and the type and length of the mortgage when considering a mortgage refinance. Pay particular attention to the annual percentage rate (APR), which includes both the interest rate and fees, to help compare various offerings. Research the history and background of any potential lender to protect yourself from refinance scams. When used responsibly, refinancing your mortgage can lead to lower monthly payments, better interest rates and an improved financial situation that can benefit you in the long run.

President & CEO of Michigan Legacy Credit Union

In order to lower the refinance costs, borrowers should shop for offers from multiple lenders and be ready to negotiate some of the fees. The upfront refinancing costs include the loan application fees, origination fees, home appraisal fees, recording fees, flood certification fees, homeowners insurance fees, title search and insurance fees, attorney fees and other closing costs. The breakeven point is calculated by dividing the closing costs by the monthly interest savings. For example, if closing costs are $7,800 and we can save $600 per month in interest, then it will take 13 months to breakeven. So, how long you’re staying in the house will tell you if you break even or not. 

Interest savings can also increase if switching from a 30-year mortgage to a 15-year mortgage. Even though the monthly payments are slightly higher, short-term loans have advantages such as: building equity sooner, paying off the loan quicker, being debt free and paying less in interest overall. Still, if people have higher-interest liabilities, then it is best to pay them off, such as credit card debt. If the rate of return on some investment opportunities is higher and the risks are manageable than the savings on the mortgage, it does not make sense to choose a shorter-term loan. Another consideration is taxes. If you pay the loan sooner, you lose the tax benefits. The goal is to look at the big picture and to move closer to your long-term financial goals.

President & CEO of Michigan Legacy Credit Union

It would help if you didn't refinance for the sake of refinancing. There are refinancing costs, so you should typically use a 1.5% reduction in rate to consider a refinance. Lenders offer no-cost or low-cost refinances, which would allow only a 1% reduction in rate. FHA and VA offer streamlined refinances that limit paperwork (no W-2s or pay stubs). I also like it when consumers do a cash-out refinance to consolidate debt. It is optimal when the borrower cuts the first mortgage term because the minimum payments on their credit cards or installment loans coupled with their mortgage are often times more than they would pay on a 15-year mortgage. You can typically show the borrower that those debts will be paid off in 3.5 to 4 years. They then must exercise discipline so as not to run up the debt anymore.

Have a question?

Ask a question, it’s free

Ask an expert
Loading...

Comments have been edited for clarity.

9 Common Mistakes People Make When Refinancing—and How to Avoid Them

  1. 1
    Not Shopping Around

    If you fail to shop around and compare rates and terms, you could end up paying more than you should. Your refinance will probably be one of the biggest financial transactions of your life, so choosing the right mortgage and the right lender can save you thousands of dollars.

  2. 2
    Opening New Credit Cards

    If you are in the process of applying for a refinance, don't obtain additional debt. In other words, don't go out and buy, say, a car while a refinance application is pending. Taking on additional debt affects the ratios that lenders use to qualify you for the mortgage. Even if you fail to disclose the new debt, whether it be a credit card or a college loan, the lender will pick it up during the application process, and it will affect your ability to qualify. So once you start the refinance application process, don't apply for any new debt until after you close on the loan.

  3. 3
    Not Gathering Required Documents Ahead of Time

    Your lender will ask for a lot of documentation, including pay stubs, tax returns, the title insurance policy and more. Start gathering these documents before you apply for a refinance. The quicker you can provide all the necessary documents, the faster and easier your application process will be.

  4. 4
    Failing to Get Accurate Quotes on Fees in Advance

    Many times the quotes you get on the phone for closing costs are actually estimates because the lender may not be familiar with the particulars of your local area. It's not unusual for closing costs, title insurance premiums and even escrow amounts to be underestimated by lenders.

  5. 5
    Choosing the Wrong Term

    If you've already been in your home for five or six years, don't extend your term by refinancing into a new 30-year loan. Instead, refinance into a 25- or 20-year loan. Since interest rates have probably come down significantly since you took out the original mortgage, you may be able to keep your payment the same but shorten the term of the mortgage. Refinancing into a new 30-year loan when you have already paid down your mortgage for a number of years will cost you a substantial amount of interest over that term.

  6. 6
    Not Paying Attention to the Appraisal Process

    In most cases, an appraisal will be required when you refinance your mortgage. Obviously, you want your house to appraise for the highest price possible. That's why it's important to be present when the appraisal takes place and to cooperate and provide information to the bank's appraiser. Appraisers need to know about major upgrades to systems, renovations and additions. The more information you can provide your appraiser that helps him or her value the home as highly as possible, the better.

  7. 7
    Failing To Check and Repair Your Credit Prior to Applying for a Mortgage Refinance

    The interest rate on your new mortgage will be determined in part by your credit score. To expedite approval of your refinance, review your credit report and clean up any problems you discover.

  8. 8
    Misrepresenting Facts on Your Refinance Application

    It might be tempting to overstate your income, stretch out how long you've been working for an employer or say that you personally occupy your home when in fact you rent it out. Don't. Misrepresentation on a mortgage application is a violation of federal law and comes with hefty penalties. You'll be found out anyway because the lender will verify all information on the application.

  9. 9
    Forgetting That Your Lender is Not Your Servicer

    It's common for loans to be sold on the secondary market, to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or to a large bank. The lender that takes your application and manages the loan closing may not be the company you deal with over the life of your loan. When your loan is sold, you start a new relationship with the loan servicing company.

About Christopher Boston


Christopher Boston headshot

Christopher (Croix) Boston was the Head of Loans content at MoneyGeek, with over five years of experience researching higher education, mortgage and personal loans.

Boston has a bachelor's degree from the Seattle Pacific University. They pride themselves in using their skills and experience to create quality content that helps people save and spend efficiently.