Rates can vary greatly by driver age and the vehicle model year. A 40-year old driver of a 2011 Chevrolet Cruze, for example, should expect to pay around $1,276 annually for car insurance. However, average rates are over four times as high ($5,917 per year) for a 16-year old driving the same vehicle. Meanwhile, a 2019 Chevrolet Cruze costs $1,543 annually for a 40-year old driver, and $7,017 per year for a 16-year old driver.
MoneyGeek also ranked insurers based on how they balance affordability with service and claims experience.