Best Cheap Car Insurance for Seniors


Enter your ZIP code to get started

Shield

Free. Simple. Secure.

Key Takeaways

blueCheck icon

State Farm delivers the best auto insurance for seniors, earning the highest MoneyGeek score in our analysis of 85 out of 100. They also offer the cheapest full coverage for seniors at $114/month.

blueCheck icon

For those with budget in mind, GEICO provides the most affordable liability-only rates for seniors, at an average of $52 per month.

blueCheck icon

Although USAA ranks high for the best and cheapest car insurance for seniors, it's only available to active military members, veterans and their families.

Compare Auto Insurance Rates

Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

Which Companies Have the Best Car Insurance for Seniors?

The best car insurance for seniors is offered by State Farm, costing an average of $114 per month for a full coverage policy. The best car insurance for seniors blends affordability, customer service and financial stability. Rates typically begin to increase when you turn 65, as insurance companies consider seniors slightly riskier to insure than other adult drivers.

Best-Rated Car Insurance For Seniors

For the providers below, we analyzed the national averages for a full coverage policy of 100/300/100 with a $1,000 deductible for drivers aged 65. We used a weighted ranking system detailed in our methodology to determine the best car insurance providers for seniors. Below are the ratings for each top provider:

USAA$1054.932.452.50
State Farm$1143.932.102.50
GEICO$1213.772.162.50
Nationwide$1283.132.393.75
Allstate$1543.271.953.75
Progressive$1553.312.353.75
Travelers$1563.582.513.75
Farmers$1703.472.293.70

Car Insurance For Seniors Ratings

Best Full Coverage Car Insurance For Seniors: State Farm

Company logo for State Farm
State Farm
MoneyGeek Score:
85/ of 100

Customer Satisfaction4.00
Claims Score2.00
Coverage Score3.00
Stability Score5.00
Annual Premium$819
Overview

State Farm is our top pick for seniors. In addition to offering top notch customer service, the provider has the best full coverage rates and a wide range of discounts. During the quote process, we secured a safe Safe Driver Discount (up to 30%) a Defensive Driving Course Discount (up to 15%), and a Low Mileage Discount for driving fewer miles.

Our Experience:

  • Availability: Ease of reaching customer service stood out immediately
  • Personalization: Friendly agents didn’t rush explaining policy options.
  • User-Friendly App: The mobile app is easy to use for the less tech-savvy.
  • Smoothe Payments: We had no trouble with payments or accessing insurance cards via the app

Best Car Insurance for Senior Veterans: USAA

Company logo for USAA
USAA
MoneyGeek Score:
90/ of 100

Customer Satisfaction5.00
Claims Score3.00
Coverage Score3.00
Stability Score5.00
Annual Premium$658.00
Overview

USAA offers the lowest rates for seniors, although coverage is limited to military members, veterans, and their families. Along with affordable rates and useful digital tools, USAA stands out for high customer satisfaction ratings that are above the industry average. With USAA, it's easy to file a claim over the phone, where agents take every aspect of claims administration seriously.

Our Experience:

  • Fast Quotes: We found USAA'online quote process to be quick and easy
  • Less Personal: Many seniors may prefer a more personal touch
  • Extra Savings: We were offered a SafePilot™ safe driving discount
  • Mobile App: Allows you to centrally manage claims, payments, and policy info

Most Affordable Car Insurance For Seniors: Geico

Company logo for GEICO
GEICO
MoneyGeek Score:
85/ of 100

Customer Satisfaction4
Claims Score2.00
Coverage Score3.00
Stability Score5.00
Annual Premium$923
Overview

With the cheapest liability-only coverage available to most drivers, Geico is our pick for most affordable car insurance for seniors. Along with affordable coverage and great customer service, Geico has several dicount offerings tailored for seniors, including a Defensive Driving Discount (10% savings), Good Driver Discount, discount for retired federal employees, and additional savings with the DriveEasy usage-based program.

Our Experience:

  • Customer Service: Agents were friendly and helpful.
  • Accessible Savings: They helped us find the best discounts and explained everything clearly.
  • Availability: You can reach their team 24/7 by phone or chat
  • Wait Times: Took more time to connect with an agent

Best Car Insurance Discounts For Seniors

Below, you can compare discounts from the top 3 insurance providers for seniors. We also provide a more detailed overview of auto insurance discounts in the guide at the bottom of the page.

Discount
State Farm
USAA
Geico

Safe Driver Discount

Up to 30%

Up to 10%

Up to 26%

Defensive Driving Discount

5-15%

3-10%

Up to 10%

Low Mileage Discount

*Yes

*Yes

*Yes

Multiple Vehicle Discount

Up to 20%

Up to 15%

Up to 25%

Home & Auto Bundle

Up to 17%

*Yes

Up to 25%

*Varies by state or location

Cheap Car Insurance For Seniors

On average, the cheapest car insurance for most senior drivers costs $621 per year or $51 per month for a minimum liability coverage policy from Geico. In the sections below, we ranked the best car insurance rates for seniors by different driver profiles, listing the average monthly and annual premiums for each provider. If you’re looking to save money, reducing your coverage or raising your deductible could result in lower car insurance premiums.

Best Car Insurance Rates For Seniors

While Geico offers the cheapest car insurance for most seniors, the cheapest car insurance option for you depends on your situation and needs, including your vehicle type, income, savings and more. In the table below, you can see the cheapest car insurance rates for seniors for each major driver profile:

Cheapest OverallGEICO$622$52
Full CoverageState Farm$1,369$114
With A Speeding TicketState Farm$450$37
With An AccidentState Farm$491$41
With A DUIState Farm$572$48
VeteranUSAA$543$45

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies For Seniors

Along with Geico, State Farm and Nationwide have the cheapest car insurance rates for most drivers. Use the table below to find the most affordable car insurance rates for you:

USAA$45$543
GEICO$52$622
State Farm$52$626
Nationwide$59$702
Progressive$68$810
Travelers$69$825
Allstate$77$918
Farmers$77$929

**The table above highlights the cheapest minimum liability policies available to most seniors. Keep in mind that USAA is only available for veterans, active servicemembers, and their families. *

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors by State

Car insurance costs vary by state, and the cheapest option for seniors in your state may differ from the national level. Use the table below to find the most affordable provider in your state.

MichiganTravelers$94$8
IowaState Farm$136$11
IdahoState Farm$145$12
MontanaState Farm$154$13
NebraskaAmerican National P&C$157$13
North DakotaNodak Mutual$158$13
MassachusettsState Farm$167$14
OhioErie$170$14
AlabamaCincinnati Insurance$175$15
WyomingState Farm$182$15
VermontState Farm$188$16
ArkansasHanover$191$16
TennesseeState Farm$197$16
OklahomaState Farm$200$17
South DakotaState Farm$204$17
HawaiiGEICO$217$18
KansasNationwide$218$18
MaineCountryway Insurance$221$18
IndianaState Farm$222$18
MississippiProgressive$227$19
KentuckyCincinnati Insurance$228$19
North CarolinaNationwide$230$19
WisconsinState Farm$232$19
New HampshireState Farm$233$19
IllinoisMercury$235$20
New MexicoState Farm$239$20
PennsylvaniaErie$242$20
ColoradoAmerican National P&C$248$21
VirginiaMercury$251$21
South CarolinaAmerican National P&C$283$24
WashingtonPEMCO$284$24
GeorgiaCountry Financial$285$24
TexasTexas Farm Bureau$295$25
West VirginiaErie$300$25
AlaskaState Farm$300$25
MinnesotaState Farm$305$25
ArizonaMercury$321$27
ConnecticutGEICO$326$27
District of ColumbiaChubb$345$29
Rhode IslandState Farm$356$30
OregonState Farm$360$30
UtahFarmers Union Insurance$369$31
MissouriState Farm$381$32
NevadaCSAA$402$33
CaliforniaGEICO$411$34
New JerseyGEICO$420$35
DelawareTravelers$444$37
FloridaGEICO$446$37
New YorkKemper$468$39
MarylandProgressive$538$45
LouisianaState Farm$541$45

The Best Car Insurance Rates for Seniors by Age

Car insurance rates for seniors typically change as they age, with lower premiums often available in their mid-50s. However, rates usually start increasing after age 70 due to higher perceived risks. Understanding how age impacts your premium can help you budget and find the best possible rates.

55State Farm$100
60Travelers$137
65State Farm$95
70State Farm$99
75State Farm$107
80State Farm$118
85State Farm$128
90GEICO$131

Best Car Insurance Rates for Seniors With A Driving Violation

Having a recent traffic citation on your record, — or several tickets over the years —whether it be from a DUI, speeding ticket, or accident, can increase your car insurance costs. Check the tables below to see how different violations impact rates of senior drivers.

Best Car Insurance Rates for Seniors With a Ticket

Our analysis found that State Farm offers the cheapest car insurance for seniors with a speeding ticket, costing an average of $77 per month or $925 per year. The table below shows the cost of car insurance for senior drivers with a speeding ticket.

USAA$787$66
State Farm$925$77
Nationwide$1,082$90
GEICO$1,236$103
Allstate$1,347$112
Travelers$1,450$121
Farmers$1,503$125
Progressive$1,511$126

Best Car Insurance Rates for Seniors After an Accident

For seniors with an accident on record, State Farm is the least expensive car insurance provider. On average, a policy costs $84 per month or $1,004 per year. The table below provides the rates for different providers for senior drivers with an at-fault accident.

State Farm$1,004$84
USAA$1,005$84
Nationwide$1,310$109
Travelers$1,548$129
GEICO$1,593$133
Allstate$1,631$136
Farmers$1,892$158
Progressive$1,910$159
mglogo icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Highway Loss Data Institute, drivers aged 70 and above have higher accident frequency per mile than middle-aged adults.

Best Car Insurance Rates for Seniors With a DUI

For seniors with a DUI on their driving record, State Farm offers the lowest car insurance rates for most drivers costing $45 per month or $544 per year. Below is the complete list of cheapest providers.

USAA$544$45
State Farm$572$48
Progressive$695$58
Farmers$858$71
Travelers$874$73
Nationwide$936$78
Allstate$944$79
GEICO$1,190$99

Car Insurance For Seniors Buying Guide

Finding the right car insurance as a senior can help you save money while ensuring adequate coverage. As you age, your needs and risks may change, affecting the type of policy you require. This guide will help you understand key factors to consider, such as coverage options, discounts for senior drivers, and how lifestyle changes like reduced driving or health conditions can impact your premiums.

How To Get The Best Car Insurance Rates For Seniors

For the most part, drivers in the middle-age brackets typically have the lowest car insurance rates, but there are ways to lower your premium after turning 55. While it may be time-consuming to implement some of these steps, the savings could be worth it when you find cheap car insurance for senior citizens.

1
Shop around for a new policy

Companies continually change how they evaluate drivers; therefore, when you’re ready to renew your policy, always shop around with at least three companies to get personalized quotes. Switching car insurance companies could help you save.

2
Update your driver status

If you haven’t updated your policy in a while, double-check the “listed drivers.” Removing people who no longer drive your vehicle from your policy could reduce your rates.

3
Take a defensive driver class

Many car insurance companies offer discounts for drivers who complete a certified defensive driver class. Check with your car insurance company for recommended courses

4
Choose a cheaper car to insure

Car insurance companies evaluate risk based on the type of vehicle you have, so choosing a less risky car — say, a four-door sedan rather than a sports car — could result in significant premium savings.

5
Increase your deductible

If you have the financial means to pay a higher car insurance deductible if you file a claim, you could reduce the amount of your premium.

6
Bundle your insurance coverage

Most car insurance companies offer multi-car and multi-policy discounts if you insure more than two vehicles or purchase both your car and homeowners insurance from the same company.

7
Add protective technology

Many car insurance companies offer discounts if your car contains safety features like a car alarm or airbags.

8
Apply discounts

Most car insurance companies offer various discounts, ranging from safe driver discounts for good driving history to discounts for automatic premium payments. Many companies also now offer discounts based on your driving habits, monitored using technology installed on your car and your smartphone.

9
Pay in full

While monthly payments have a lower upfront cost, many insurance providers offer discounts that range from 5-10% for paying for a policy in full.

10
Consider usage-based insurance

If you drive less, a usage-based policy that tracks your driving habits via a device or app could offer significant savings.

Car Insurance Discounts For Seniors

Seniors can take advantage of several car insurance discounts to lower their premiums. Options like pay-per-mile programs, low-mileage discounts, and defensive driving courses offer savings tailored to seniors' driving habits. Additionally, bundling policies and maintaining a clean driving record can lead to significant reductions. Explore these discounts to get the best rates as your insurance needs evolve.

    car2Colored icon

    Pay-Per-Mile Programs

    These programs are ideal for seniors who don’t drive as much as they used to. Your premium is based on the number of miles driven, so the less you drive, the less you pay. This is especially useful for retirees who no longer commute regularly.

    piggyBank icon

    Low-Mileage Discount

    Many insurance companies offer discounts for seniors who drive fewer miles each year. If you stay below a certain mileage threshold, you can qualify for lower rates, which is perfect for those who mainly use their car for errands or occasional trips.

    onlineForms icon

    Defensive Driving Discount

    Completing a certified defensive driving course can earn seniors a discount on their car insurance. These courses refresh your driving skills and help reduce risk, making insurers more likely to offer savings.

    homeInsurance icon

    Multi Policy

    Bundling your auto insurance with other policies, such as home or renters insurance, can lead to significant savings. Many insurers offer discounts for combining coverage, allowing seniors to lower their overall insurance costs.

    injury icon

    Accident Free Discount

    If you’ve maintained a clean driving record without any accidents, you may qualify for an accident-free discount. Insurers reward safe drivers with lower premiums, making it a valuable perk for seniors who have a long history of responsible driving.

Average Senior Car Insurance Rates For Seniors

Across all coverage levels, the average cost of car insurance for seniors 55 and up is $1188 per year or $99 per month. Average car insurance rates for seniors vary based on factors like age, location, driving history, and coverage needs. While seniors in their mid-50s often enjoy some of the lowest rates, premiums typically rise after age 70 due to increased risk factors.

Average Senior Car Insurance Rates by Coverage Type

Senior car insurance coverage ranges from basic liability car insurance, which is required by most states, to full coverage, which covers both your expenses and those of the other driver if you're at fault. Full coverage also protects against non-accident-related damage and theft. The amount of coverage you need depends on your financial situation, but higher coverage limits can help protect your assets.

The table below shows the average rates for senior drivers by different coverage types.

Coverage
Policy Type and Deductible
Annual Premium
Monthly Premium

State Minimum

Liability-Only

$477

$40

State Minimum

Full Coverage $1500 Deductible

$828

$69

State Minimum

Full Coverage $1000 Deductible

$870

$73

State Minimum

Full Coverage $500 Deductible

$978

$81

100/300/100

Liability-Only

$591

$49

Cheapest Car Insurance for Seniors - Best Rates Oct '24

Finding the best car insurance rates for seniors is not a one-size-fits-all process. Each car insurance company evaluates drivers based on their personalized factors — your age, location, vehicle type, driving history and credit-based insurance score. Therefore, getting customized quotes from several companies is important for finding the cheapest car insurance available.

Car Insurance For Seniors: FAQ

Older adults have unique needs when it comes to auto insurance. Learn the answers to frequently asked questions about car insurance to help you find the best deal to meet your needs.

What is the best car insurance for seniors?
What is the cheapest car insurance for senior citizens?
Does car insurance increase at age 70?
Loading...

Car Insurance For Seniors Reviews: Our Ratings Methodology

To determine the best car insurance providers for seniors, we collected data from independent sources and created a weighted scoring system.

  • 30% Customer satisfaction: Data collected from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) customer complaint index and J.D. Power customer satisfaction scoring determined customer service satisfaction.
  • 30% Affordability: Data collected from Quadrant Information Services. Affordability scoring analyzes how rate costs compare between providers. **- 20% Claims: Data collected from J.D. Power Claims Study and the Crash Report Card determined customer satisfaction when making a claim
  • 10% Coverage: We hand-collected coverage offerings and data from car insurance providers to determine if the insurer offered essential coverages most drivers need.
  • 5% Financial Stability: AM Best provides financial stability ratings that assist in determining the insurers' record of meeting financial obligations with claims.

Study Overview to Determine Cheapest Providers for Seniors

To determine car insurance rates and comparisons, we collected data from State insurance departments and Quadrant information systems. We analyzed 706,104 quotes from 67 companies across 897 zip codes to determine national and state-specific rate averages.

Sample Driver Profile

To collect rate cost data, we used a sample driver profile and modified it to collect data on personalized factors such as age, geographic location, or driving history. The sample driver profiles are as follows:

  • 2010 Toyota Camry LE
  • 12K miles driven annually
  • Male drivers
  • Drivers ages 60, 65, 70, 75, 80, 85 and 90
  • Drivers with a clean driving record, with a ticket, accident or DUI.
  • Policies, Coverages, and Deductibles Explained

Using our sample driver profiles, we collected rate costs for full coverage as well as liability-only coverage. We also collected data on coverage amounts.100/300/100 is shorthand for:

  • $100,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $300,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $100,000 property damage liability

300/500/300 is shorthand for:

  • $300,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $500,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • 300,000 property damage liability

Coverage requirements are determined at the state level. We collected data on state-specific rates using the state’s coverage requirements to determine state and national averages for state minimum coverage requirements. In the event of an incident or accident, a deductible is the amount you will pay before your insurance kicks in. We applied the following deductibles to all of the coverages and policies listed above:

No deductible (Liability-only policies)

  • $500 deductible
  • $1,000 deductible
  • $1,500 deductible

Learn more about MoneyGeeks car insurance methodology.

About Karon Warren


Karon Warren headshot

Karon Warren is a finance journalist at MoneyGeek and a member of the American Society of Journalists and Authors. She has over two decades of experience covering personal finance, health insurance, home insurance, car insurance, mortgages and banking.

Warren earned her journalism degree from the University of Southern Mississippi. She creates in-depth, well-researched finance content that educates people and helps them make informed financial decisions.


sources